Manganese in drinking water has recently come under scrutiny due to its potential effect on human health as well as its damage to the distribution systems of public water systems. EPA and the state of South Dakota are currently evaluating these effects. EPA has established a Health Advisory Level for Manganese in drinking water. EPAâ€™s Secondary Drinking Water Standards identify manganese as having technical (staining) and aesthetic effects (taste, color). For more information about the health effects and aesthetic effects of Manganese, click on this link to view a document on Frequently Asked Questions About Manganese in Drinking Water.
Manganese is a common, naturally-occurring mineral found in rocks, soil, groundwater, and surface water. Manganese is a natural component of most foods. Manganese is an essential nutrient and eating a small amount of it each day is important to stay healthy.
The majority of manganese exposure in the general population comes from the food we eat. Grains, beans, nuts and teas are rich in manganese and it is also found in infant formula. A normal, balanced diet typically provides adequate manganese intake. The principal source of exposure to manganese is from food, but in situations where manganese levels in drinking water are elevated, the contribution from drinking water can increase the overall intake of manganese.
Adults and children get enough manganese from the foods we eat. For example, EPAâ€™s drinking water health advisory for manganese says:
No. Manganese is not currently regulated as a national primary drinking water standard which means
there is no enforceable limit for manganese in drinking water. However, EPA is in the process of
determining whether to regulate manganese due to updated health effects information and additional
occurrence data. EPA included manganese in the fourth Unregulated Contaminant Monitoring Rule
(UCMR4), which requires all public drinking water systems serving over 10,000 people and selected
small systems to monitor for manganese. EPA will also consider the health effects in their
regulatory determination and evaluate potential risks to adults, children, and infants based on
Some states have set their own standards for manganese. South Dakota law does not allow our state to have regulations that are more stringent than EPA regulations. Therefore, South Dakota is not able to establish a drinking water standard for manganese. EPA has established a Secondary Drinking Water standard for manganese. EPAâ€™s Secondary Drinking Water Standards identify manganese as having technical (staining) and aesthetic effects (taste, color).
More information on EPAâ€™s regulatory determination process can be found at the following link: https://www.epa.gov/dwregdev/how-epa-regulates-drinking-water-contaminants.
More information on the UCMR4 can be found at the following link: https://www.epa.gov/dwucmr/fourth-unregulated-contaminant-monitoring-rule
The EPA develops health advisories to provide information on contaminants that can cause human health effects and are known (or anticipated) to occur in drinking water. Health advisories are intended to provide technical guidance to agencies and local officials. Health advisories are set at levels that will protect people from all adverse health effects. Published health advisory levels are based on non-cancer health effects for specified exposure durations; one-day, ten-day, and lifetime.
One-day and 10-day health advisories are considered acute or short-term levels that are not expected to cause adverse effects for up to one or ten days of exposure. These health advisories are intended to protect a 10-kg (22 pound) child consuming 1 liter of water per day.
Lifetime health advisories are considered chronic or long-term levels that are not expected to cause adverse effects after a lifetime of exposure. These health advisories are intended to protect a 70-kg (154 pound) adult consuming 2 liters of water per day.
The EPA health advisory levels of 0.3 mg/L and 1 mg/L were set based upon typical daily dietary manganese intake levels not known to be associated with adverse health effects. This does not imply that intakes above these levels will necessarily cause health problems. As a precaution, the general population should consider limiting their consumption of drinking water when levels of manganese are above the EPA health advisory to decrease their exposures and to decrease the possibility of adverse neurological effects.
Too much manganese can increase the risk of health problems, particularly for infants under 6
months old. Infants are more at risk than older children and adults because their brains and
bodies are quickly developing. Infants exposed to manganese over 0.3 mg/L may experience learning
or behavioral problems. Some studies have shown that too much manganese during childhood may also
have effects on the brain, which may affect learning and behavior.
Manganese is poorly absorbed through the skin. There are no concerns about manganese exposure through skin contact with food or water containing manganese.
Adultâ€™s drinking water with high levels of manganese for many years may experience impacts to their nervous system, resulting in behavioral changes and other nervous system effects, including slow and clumsy movements. Exposure to high levels of manganese can cause harm to the nervous system. A disorder similar to Parkinsonâ€™s disease called Manganism can result. Tremors, shaking, and an unsteady gait are characteristic of very high exposure to manganese. This type of effect is most likely to occur in the elderly after exposure to high levels of manganese or with individuals exposed to welding vapor that contains high levels of manganese. The EPAâ€™s health advisory is intended to protect against this effect.
If you are concerned about your health from manganese exposure, discuss your concerns with your healthcare provider.
Yes, especially for bottle-fed infants. All commercial baby formulas contain manganese as a nutrient, and if prepared with water that also contains manganese, the infant may get a higher dose than recommended. Some studies suggest that prenatal and early childhood exposures to manganese can have effects on learning and behavior. Thus, it is very important to know what the manganese levels in drinking water are when using it to make baby formula.
When manganese levels in drinking water are above 0.3 mg/L, infants under 6 months of age should immediately stop consuming the water and formula that was prepared with the water.
If you get your water from a public water supply system, you can look up water quality information for your system by following this link: https://denr.sd.gov/des/dw/sysinfo.aspx . Once you find your system from the list, the link titled â€œWater hardness, pH, and other informationâ€ should be selected. This report contains water quality information gathered by DENR during routine inspections at your water system. The column with the heading â€œMnâ€ provides a summary of the data collected by DENR with an average of the data at the bottom of the table. If you canâ€™t find your water system, contact DENR at 1-800-GET-DENR or a representative of your public water supply system and request the concentrations of manganese. Please be aware that not all systems are required to test for manganese.
If you obtain your water from a private well and suspect high manganese in your drinking water, you should contact a lab certified to analyze for manganese in drinking water and have your supply tested. The South Dakota Department of Healthâ€™s Public Health Laboratory tests drinking water for manganese. The fee for the test is $14. Testing kits are available at the State Public Health Laboratory at 615 E. Fourth Street, Pierre, SD 57501. 605-773-3368. A list of labs certified to analyze drinking water can be found at the following link: https://denr.sd.gov/des/dw/certie.aspx
Consider filtering your drinking water or using an alternate source of drinking water. Oxidizing filters, reverse osmosis units, or water softeners have been shown to be effective at lowering manganese levels in tap water, depending on the form of manganese in your water (dissolved or particulate. For instance, water drawn from the tap is initially clear but over time develops a brown or blackish hue as it is exposed to the air would indicate that the manganese is dissolved. If water coming out of the tap immediately colored brown or blackish with particulates settling out, you would consider that particulate manganese). NSF International, the Water Quality Association, Underwriters Laboratories, and CSA International all certify home water treatment products for contaminant removal. Keep in mind that certification to an NSF/ANSI or other standard or protocol does not mean that a filter, purifier, or treatment system will reduce all possible contaminants. Itâ€™s important to verify that the filter, purifier or treatment system is certified to the applicable standard for the reduction of the contaminants of most concern.
For more information on home filtration treatment system certification, you can go to the following link: https://www.nsf.org/consumer-resources/water-quality/water-filters-testing- treatment/standards-water-treatment-systems.
Filters found in refrigerators, water pitchers, or filters installed on your water tap are not effective at removing Manganese and one should check with the filter manufacturer for specific detail.
Boiling water will not remove manganese. Boiling will concentrate manganese.
Each home plumbing and treatment system is unique, and some homes may not have treated tap water available at the taps most used for drinking and cooking. Also, keep in mind that any type of treatment device requires regular maintenance, such as changing filters, cleaning scale buildup, maintaining adequate salt levels in brine tanks, or disinfecting the unit. Failure to properly maintain a unit reduces its effectiveness and, in some cases, may make the water quality worse. Continued maintenance is necessary for the life of the device along with regular water testing to ensure the device is working properly. Ensuring your system is working properly minimizes the need for testing. Follow the manufacturerâ€™s recommendations for filter replacements and maintenance.
If you are concerned about your in-home treatment systems effectiveness to remove manganese, water testing is available. The South Dakota Department of Healthâ€™s Public Health Laboratory tests drinking water for manganese. The fee for the test is $14. Testing kits are available at the State Public Health Laboratory at 615 E. Fourth Street, Pierre, SD 57501. 605-773-3368. A list of labs certified to analyze drinking water can be found at the following link: https://denr.sd.gov/des/dw/certie.aspx.
You may choose to reduce your exposure to manganese by using another source of water such as bottled water. However, manganese may still be present in bottled water. Contact the bottled water manufacturer for more water quality information.
EPAâ€™s Secondary Drinking Water Standards: https://www.epa.gov/dwstandardsregulations/secondary-drinking-water-standards-guidance- nuisance-chemicals
State Hygienic Laboratory at the University of Iowa Well Water Quality and Home Treatment Systems: http://shl.uiowa.edu/env/privatewell/homewater.pdf
Frequently Asked Questions About Manganese from the Centers for Disease Control: https://www.atsdr.cdc.gov/toxfaqs/tfacts151.pdf
For additional health related inquiries regarding manganese in drinking water, contact Bob Benson at 303-312-7070.
For additional questions or information, please contact Mark Mayer, P.E. Drinking Water Program Administrator at 605-773-3754.